QUESTIONS AND CLASS DISCUSSION



   In some areas of the world the traditional educational approach is to have the teacher impart information through set lectures and study assignments.  There is little student participation except in memorizing and repeating back what is learned.  But in religious education, effective teaching is edifying teaching, and people are more likely to be edified when they participate in learning under the influence of the Spirit (see Role of the Student)  Asking good questions and directing effective discussions are primary ways to encourage that participation.  A discussion is when a teacher verbally interacts with students and students interact with each other in a manner that fosters learning.  A good discussion can help students learn the value of personal inquiry in their own lives.  they need to learn how to ask for help from the Lord and then to search for answers.  A stimulating discussion is also a way to encourage students to apply what they have learn.  Following are some ideas for developing stimulating questions and  directing inspiring and persuasive discussions:


1. Ask questions that stimulate thinking and encourage student response.
     Questions can be asked that lead students to search for information, analyze what they are studying, or help them apply it in their own lives.  Teachers should avoid questions that can be answered with a simple yes or no, or where the answer is so obvious the students are not motivated to think about it.

    • Good questions require students to search the scriptures for the answer and to seek the Spirit's help.  Such questions often begin with words such as who, what, when, how, where, and why.
    • When teaching the scriptures, questions that help students think about the meaning of a scripture verse are good.  These questions are usually asked after students have become familiar with the verses. They may have more than one possible answer and could help students start a discussion. They often begin with phrases like "Why do you think...." or "How is it that....."
    • Ask students to apply what they have learned from the verses.  These questions may also have more than one possible answer.  For example, "Why should prayer be one of the first things we do each day?  What difference would it make if it was?" or "What did you learn from the example of Abraham that you could apply to your life?"
    • Ask students to compare things, such as asking them to compare a person or an event in one part of the scriptures to another person or event somewhere else.
    • Good questions are at the very heart of good discussions.  A good question should be stimulating and challenging, but usually not controversial or sensational.  Sometimes teachers will ask a controversial question just to stimulate a lively discussion.  This may frustrate the students and create contention in the class, which grieves the Spirit (see 3 Nephi 11:29).

2. Plan the discussion
  
Like other methods of teaching, a discussion needs to be carefully prepared and then conducted under the influence of the Spirit, following principles of edification.  The teacher needs to have thought out the purpose of the discussion (how it will help students understand what they need to learn), what series of questions will lead to that purpose, how to ask those questions in the most effective manner, and how to respond if student answers lead off in an unwanted direction.  Throughout the discussion the teacher needs to encourage learner participation.  The whole purpose of discussion is to get students involved in the gospel learning experience so they begin to discover principles and concepts for themselves and then have the Spirit testify to them of their truthfulness.


3. Call on students by name.
   When a teacher does not specify the person who is expected to answer, often only the bolder students will reply.  It can be useful not to designate to whom the question is directed until after the question is asked.  When a name is specified first, other students may relax and feel they do not need to think about the question.  Also, there will always be some students who want to answer almost every question.  By calling on other students by name, the teacher can get responses from others less likely to participate.


4. Give students time to think
   Some times teachers ask a question, pause for a second or two, then when no one immediately responds, panic and give the answer themselves.  Be patient.  Students often need time to find the answer in the scriptures or to think about the question and what they want to say.  The silence should not trouble the teacher if it does not go on too long.  On the other hand, sometimes there is no response because the question is not clear.  If this is the case, the teacher may need to rephrase the question or ask the students if they understand what was asked.


5. Listen to  the students' answers
   Teachers are sometimes so concerned about what to say or do next that they do not pay attention to what students are saying.  A teacher can make sure that he or she understands the answers by asking questions like "What do you mean by that?" or "Give me an example of what you mean.  Questions can be redirected to other students to maintain full class participation.  Usually, unless time is limited, all students who want to give an answer should have an opportunity to speak.  Teachers can remind students to listen to each other and to not talk when someone else is speaking (see D&C 88:122)
 


    Unit 4

aarrowanimated.gif
aarrowanimated.gif
Sitemap1
Home Page
animatedorb.gif

Site Mapper

Summary
animatedorb.gif